When a loved one signs a will that seems unusual or out of character, family members may question whether the person understood what they were doing. A lack-of-capacity challenge depends on evidence showing whether the person had testamentary capacity when the testator signed the will.
What must you prove about the testator’s capacity?
Florida law requires a person making a will to be of sound mind. Florida courts generally describe testamentary capacity as the ability to understand the nature and extent of the property being disposed of, the people who would ordinarily expect to benefit from the estate and the practical effect of the will.
After the will’s proponent establishes that the will was properly executed and attested, the contestant generally bears the burden of proving grounds for the challenge, including lack of testamentary capacity.
The key issue is the person’s mental state when the testator signed the will. Dementia, mental illness or cognitive decline does not automatically invalidate a will. A person may still have testamentary capacity during a period of clarity when they execute the will.
Earlier or later changes may provide context. The evidence should help show what the person understood on or around the date of signing.
What evidence can support a lack-of-capacity claim?
A challenge may rely on evidence such as:
- Medical records from around the date the testator signed the will
- Testimony from people who observed the testator’s memory, reasoning or behavior
- Evidence of what the testator understood about the will, the estate and who would naturally claim a substantial benefit
Other facts may raise questions, but unusual facts alone do not establish lack of capacity. Their significance depends on the evidence of the testator’s mental state when they signed the will.
How can you build the evidence for a will contest?
Identify people who interacted with the testator around the signing date. Gather medical records and create a timeline of the person’s condition before, on and after the testator signed the will. Focus on observations close to the signing date.
Preserve communications and other documents related to the will. Medical testimony or testimony from qualified witnesses may help explain medical records or cognitive conditions.
What are the next steps in a Florida will contest?
Lack of capacity requires evidence tied to the time the testator signed the will. Medical records and witness accounts can help show whether the testator understood the will and the decisions they made.
For a Florida will contest involving an estate in Sarasota or Bradenton, a probate attorney can help evaluate whether the available evidence supports a capacity challenge and identify applicable deadlines and procedures.